Fundraising is the lifeblood of every nonprofit, but most fundraising advice is either too generic (“just tell your story!”) or too expensive (“hire a development director!”). Here are 15 fundraising strategies that small nonprofits can actually execute — with real budgets and small teams.

1. Monthly Giving Program

Monthly donors give 42% more per year than one-time donors. They’re also 30% more likely to renew. A monthly giving program is the highest-ROI fundraising strategy available.

How to start:

• Add a “Make it Monthly” option to every donation form
• Create a monthly giving society with a name (e.g., “The Champions Circle”)
• Send a welcome packet to new monthly donors
• Report impact annually (not just thank-you notes)
• Target $25-50/month — most donors can afford this

Tools: Your giving platform (Donorbox, Givebutter, Tithe.ly) should support recurring giving natively.

2. Peer-to-Peer Fundraising

Your supporters fundraise on your behalf. They create personal fundraising pages, share their story, and ask their network to give. One supporter with 200 social media connections can reach donors you’ll never find.

How to start:

• Choose a peer-to-peer platform (Givebutter, Classy, or Donorbox)
• Create a campaign page with a goal, timeline, and story
• Recruit 10-20 supporters to create personal pages
• Give them email templates, social media graphics, and a fundraising guide
• Celebrate milestones publicly

Expected results: Peer-to-peer campaigns raise 3-5x more than traditional campaigns on average.

3. Year-End Appeal

40% of all charitable giving happens in December. A well-executed year-end appeal can generate 20-30% of your annual revenue in one month.

How to execute:

• Start planning in October (don’t wait until December)
• Send a direct mail letter in late November
• Follow up with 3-4 emails in December
• Make the ask specific: “Your $50 provides [concrete impact]”
• Include a matching gift if possible (doubles impact, doubles response rate)
• Send the final email on December 31

Key dates: Giving Tuesday (first Tuesday after Thanksgiving), December 28-31 (peak giving days).

4. Grant Writing

Grants are not free money — they’re earned income that requires strong applications and clear impact measurement. But for small nonprofits, even one $10,000 grant can fund a program for a year.

How to start:

• Search Instrumentl, GrantWatch, or your state’s nonprofit association for grants
• Start with local foundations and community foundations (they’re more likely to fund small orgs)
• Write proposals that include: need, approach, impact, and budget
• Track outcomes and report back to funders
• Apply for 5-10 grants per quarter

Common mistake: Writing about your organization instead of the problem you solve. Funders fund impact, not organizations.

5. Crowdfunding Campaigns

Crowdfunding works best for specific, tangible projects — not general operating support. “Help us buy a new van” raises more than “support our mission.”

How to execute:

• Choose a specific, fundable project
• Set a clear goal and deadline (30-45 days)
• Create a compelling video (2-3 minutes)
• Break the goal into specific giving levels ($25 = one [item], $100 = five [items])
• Update donors weekly on progress
• Thank every donor individually

Best for: Equipment purchases, building repairs, specific program launches.

6. Corporate Sponsorships

Local businesses want to support their community — and get visibility in return. Sponsorships are a win-win: they fund your work and give businesses positive brand exposure.

How to approach:

• Create a sponsorship packet with 3-4 levels ($500, $1,000, $2,500, $5,000)
• Each level includes specific benefits (logo on website, social media mention, event signage)
• Approach businesses you have a personal connection with first
• Target businesses that align with your mission
• Follow up with a report showing what their sponsorship funded

Common mistake: Asking for money without offering value. Sponsorships are partnerships, not donations.

7. Donor Retention Program

It costs 5-7x more to acquire a new donor than to keep an existing one. Yet the average nonprofit donor retention rate is 45%. Improving retention by 10% can double your fundraising revenue over time.

How to improve retention:

• Thank donors within 48 hours (not 48 days)
• Send 3-4 impact updates per year (not just fundraising asks)
• Call first-time donors to say thank you (no ask, just gratitude)
• Report specific impact: “Your $100 provided [concrete result]”
• Ask donors what they care about (not just what you think they care about)
• Create a monthly giving program (monthly donors retain at 90%+)

Tools: Bloomerang’s engagement scoring, Little Green Light’s donor profiles.

8. Benefit Events

Galas, 5Ks, and benefit concerts raise money and build community. They also introduce your organization to new supporters.

How to execute:

• Choose an event type that fits your mission and audience
• Set a revenue goal and a budget (aim for 50%+ net revenue)
• Secure sponsors before selling tickets
• Create a budget that includes ALL costs (venue, food, marketing, swag)
• Have a clear “ask” moment at the event
• Follow up with attendees within one week

Best for: Organizations with a network of supporters who attend events.

9. Email Fundraising

Email fundraising has a 2-3% conversion rate — not flashy, but reliable and low-cost. A well-segmented email list is your most valuable fundraising asset.

How to execute:

• Build your list (not buy it) through your website, events, and social media
• Segment donors: new, lapsed, monthly, major
• Send 2-3 emails per month (not all asks — include impact stories)
• Make the ask clear and specific
• Use a PS line with the ask (most-read part of fundraising emails)
• Test subject lines, send times, and ask amounts

Tools: Mailchimp (free for under 500 contacts), Constant Contact, or your CRM’s built-in email.

10. Social Media Fundraising

Social media rarely generates large donations directly, but it’s excellent for awareness, peer-to-peer campaigns, and reaching new audiences.

How to use it:

• Share impact stories (not just asks)
• Use Facebook/Instagram fundraising for specific campaigns
• Create shareable graphics for your campaigns
• Thank donors publicly (with permission)
• Use video — it gets 5-10x more engagement than text

Realistic expectations: Social media fundraising typically generates 5-10% of total revenue for small nonprofits. Don’t overinvest here.

11. Major Gift Program

80% of your revenue likely comes from 20% of your donors. A major gift program identifies, cultivates, and asks those top donors for transformational gifts.

How to start:

• Identify your top 20 donors (by total giving and capacity)
• Research their giving capacity (public records, business affiliations)
• Build relationships before asking (tours, calls, impact updates)
• Ask for a specific amount based on their capacity
• Make the ask in person, not by email
• Follow up within 48 hours

Common mistake: Being afraid to ask for large gifts. Donors who give $1,000 are often capable of giving $10,000+ if asked properly.

12. Matching Gift Program

Over $4-7 billion in matching gifts goes unclaimed every year because donors don’t know their employers offer them. Simply promoting matching gifts can increase your revenue by 10-20%.

How to promote:

• Add a matching gift search tool to your donation page (Double the Donation offers this)
• Include matching gift information in donation confirmations
• Mention matching gifts in newsletters and appeals
• Ask donors to check with their HR department
• Follow up on submitted matching gift claims

Tools: Double the Donation, matchinggifts.com.

13. Tribute and Memorial Giving

Donors give in honor or memory of someone they love. Tribute giving provides a meaningful way to support your organization during significant life events.

How to start:

• Add “In honor of” and “In memory of” fields to your donation forms
• Send a notification to the honoree or their family
• Create a tribute wall on your website
• Promote tribute giving during holidays (Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, holidays)
• Send annual reminders to past tribute donors

14. In-Kind Donations

Not all donations are cash. In-kind donations (goods, services, expertise) reduce your expenses and engage supporters who may not be able to give financially.

How to solicit in-kind donations:

• Create a “wish list” of needed items and services
• Ask local businesses for specific in-kind contributions
• Track in-kind donations for grant reporting (they count as revenue and expenses)
• Thank in-kind donors the same way you thank cash donors
• Document everything with a written acknowledgment

Best for: Event supplies, professional services (legal, accounting, marketing), office equipment, program materials.

15. Earned Revenue

Earned revenue (charging for services, products, or events) provides unrestricted income that doesn’t depend on donor generosity. It’s the most sustainable funding model.

Examples for small nonprofits:

• Fee-for-service programs (training, workshops, consulting)
• Social enterprise (selling products related to your mission)
• Membership dues
• Event ticket sales
• Space rental (if you own a building)
• Training and certification programs

How to start: Identify one service or product you could offer that aligns with your mission and generates revenue. Test it with a small audience before scaling.

The Fundraising Mix That Works

No single strategy funds a nonprofit. The most successful small organizations combine 4-5 strategies:

1. Monthly giving (recurring, predictable revenue)

2. Year-end appeal (annual revenue spike)

3. Grant writing (project-specific funding)

4. Email fundraising (consistent, low-cost asks)

5. Major gifts (transformational revenue from top donors)

Start with 2-3 of these, execute them consistently for 6 months, then add one more. Fundraising is a long game — the organizations that win are the ones that show up consistently, not the ones that chase every shiny new strategy.

SoftDecide helps churches, nonprofits, and small organizations find the right software. Our comparisons are independently researched. We may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page — at no extra cost to you.